Fractional distillation of C2 /C3 hydrocarbons at optimum pressures

ABSTRACT

A method of recovering by distillation the separate components of a hydrocarbon gas mixture comprising ethylene, ethane, propylene and propane which comprises separating the ethylene as an overhead from an ethane, propylene and propane bottom in a first distillation tower at from about 500 to about 650 psia, separating ethane as an overhead from a propylene and propane bottom in a second distillation tower at from about 390 to about 520 psia, and separating propylene as an overhead from a propane bottom in a third distillation tower at from about 100 to about 170 psia is disclosed. 
     A method of separating ethylene and ethane from propylene and propane in a first distillation tower at from about 400 to about 600 psia, separating the overhead product from the first tower in a second tower at from about 600 to about 700 psia to produce ethylene and ethane products, and separating a propylene/propane mixture in a third tower at from about 100 to about 170 psia is disclosed. 
     The heat for operating the propylene/propane splitter is derived from the cooling water of a heat exchange system or from hot quench tower oil.

This is a division of application Ser. No. 06/299,623, filed Sept. 4, 1981, now abandoned.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

1. Field of the Invention

This invention relates to the fractional distillation of a C₂ /C₃ hydrocarbon mixture into its component parts, i.e., ethane, ethylene, propane, propylene and is more particularly concerned with the optimizing of the expense of such fractional distillation.

2. Description of the Prior Art

It is well known that refinery off-gas or pyrolysis products of many saturated hydrocarbons offer a very large potential supply of olefinic hydrocarbons such as ethylene and propylene which do not otherwise occur naturally, and that these hydrocarbons are tremendously important as chemical intermediates. These hydrocarbons are useful not only for the manufacture of synthetic alcohols and rubber but also for the production of certain types of plastics and for many other purposes. However, ethylene and propylene are normally associated with other gases such as ethane and propane from which they can only be separated at considerable expense.

Illustrative of such a separation system is U.S. Pat. No. 2,645,104 wherein a C₂ /C₃ feedstream, containing ethane, ethylene, propane and propylene is first separated by fractional distillation into an overhead stream (ethane and ethylene) and a bottoms stream (propane and propylene) and then each of these streams is separated into its components in respective second and third distillation towers.

The prior art relating to correlations which should be employed in arriving at the most economical manner of operating fractional distillation systems is that which was published by the applicant. There are: (1) D. W. Tedder, The Heuristic Synthesis and Topology of Optimal Distillation Networks, Ph.d These, Chemical Engineering, University of Wisconsin, Madison (August 1975); and (2) D. W. Tedder and D. F. Rudd, "Parametric Studies in Industrial Distillation: Part II Heuristic Optimization, "AIChE Journal 24 (2) March 1978) 323-334. However, these earlier correlations were based on bubble point feed temperatures only, and did not consider the effects of the overhead product mixture bubble point temperature and the bottoms product dew point temperature. These latter two quantities are highly important because they determine the feasible utility temperature (i.e., those of steam, refrigeration and cooling water.) Also, the earlier correlations are based on the normal feed mixture bubble point temperature (i.e., the bubble point estimated at 14.7 psia) rather than the present correlations wherein 485 psia is used as a pressure basis.

My earlier correlations do not predict the best operating pressures for mixtures of ethylene, ethane, propylene and propane. In fact many predictions using my earlier correlations are above the mixture critical point and, therefore, are not feasible.

The correlation of the present invention substantially improve on the earlier work because they predict that differences exist between towers 11, 14 and 15; and between towers 16 and 17; and between towers 18 and 19, discussed hereinafter. The earlier correlation would not predict that difference existed in these cases since it was based only on the feed bubble point. Also, the earlier correlations would predict only small differences existing between towers in the two sets (towers 11, 14, 15) and (towers 16, 17) and between towers 110 and 18, 19. As is pointed out hereinafter in Table 2, the correlations disclosed, here correctly predict that large differences do exist because of the effects of product compositions on the utility costs.

As shown in U.S. Pat. No. 2,500,353, a hydrocarbon feedstream may be subjected to serial removal of components, i.e., sequentially methane, ethylene, ethane, propylene, propane, etc. are removed from the feedstock in successive towers.

Various additional techniques are known in the distillation art for improving process economics or yields. Illustrative of such techniques are: U.S. Pat. No. 2,127,004--use of a single closed system refrigeration cycle to both reboil bottoms and condense overheads; U.S. Pat. No. 2,542,520--solvent extraction (extractive distillation); U.S. Pat. No. 2,577,617--propane absorber tower; U.S. Pat. No. 2,600,110--fractionator with refrigeration cycles; U.S. Pat. No. 2,722,113--fractional distillation of a partially condensed feedstream cooled by heat exchange with an expansion--cooled product stream; U.S. Pat. No. 2,952,983--avoidance of the formation of hydrocarbon hydrate; U.S. Pat. No. 3,119,677--recovery of hydrogen; U.S. Pat. No. 3,150,199--prevention of in-situ polymerization and by-product losses of desired components; and U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,359,743, 3,360,946, 4,140,504, 4,157,904 and 4,171,964--recovery of ethane and other components of natural gas.

A need therefore continues to exist for techniques whereby the process economics of such separations can be improved, particularly, with respect to utility costs which are a major cost burden on such processes.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

Accordingly, one object of the invention is to provide a process for the separation of ethane, ethylene, propane and propylene at reduced cost.

Another object of the invention is to provide a process for the separation of ethane, ethylene, propane and propylene operating at optimum pressures which are substantially different from those currently contemplated in the art.

Another object of the invention is to operate the towers at the most economic pressures by avoiding the use of very cold refrigerants and exploiting favorable reductions in the species latent heats of vaporization.

Another object of the invention is to operate propylene/propane splitters at optimum pressures which permit the most economical use of cooling water as a heating medium.

Another object of the invention is to operate propylene/propane splitters at optimum pressures using as a heating medium either steam or hot quench tower oil, as is typically generated by ethylene quench towers.

Briefly, these object and other objects of the invention as hereinafter will become more readily apparent can be attained by providing a method of recovering by distillation the separate components of a hydrocarbon gas mixture containing ethane, ethylene, propane and propylene, the method comprising separating ethylene as an overhead product from an ethane, propane and propylene bottom in a first tower at from about 500 psia to about 650 psia, preferably, from about 550 psia to about 570 psia; separating ethane as an overhead product from a propane and propylene bottom in a second tower at from about 390 psia to about 520 psia, preferably, from about 410 psia to about 430 psia; and separating propylene as an overhead product from a propane bottom product in a third tower at about from 100 psia to about 170 psia, preferably, from about 120 psia to about 140 psia.

Also, the invention includes the method of separating an ethylene and ethane mixture from a propylene propane mixture in a tower operating at a pressure from about 400 to about 600 psia, but preferably at from about 470 to about 490 psia. The method of separating the ethylene ethane product from the first tower, in a second tower operating from about 600 to about 700 psia, but preferably at about 660 to about 680 psia.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

A more complete appreciation of the invention and many of the attentant advantages thereof will be readily obtained as the same becomes better understood by reference to the following detailed description when considered in connection with the accompanying drawings, wherein:

FIG. 1 is a schematic representation of a distillation sequence according to the present invention;

FIG. 2 is a schematic representation of an alternative distillation sequence according to the present invention;

FIG. 3 is a schematic representation of one method of optimizing a propylene/propane tower utilities according to the present invention; and

FIG. 4 is a schematic representation of another alternate propylene/propane tower utilities optimization method according to the present invention.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

In commercial plants, the ethylene- and propylene-bearing fluid stream introduced into the recovery system contains various proportions of hydrogen, hydrocarbons and impurities such as carbon dioxide and nitrogen. The present invention relates only to that portion of the original stream fed which relates to the recovery system which contains essentially ethane, ethylene, propane and propylene, the remaining materials having been largely eliminated by processes conventional in the art.

In developing my system for predicting the optional deethanizer tower pressures which will result in the most economical recovery of the constitutents from the fluid stream, I derived certain empirical correlations. In arriving at this correlation ten different simple distillation towers, including those shown in FIGS. 1 and 2, were used to develop empirical correlations for predicting the optimal operating pressures for individual distillation towers that separate mixtures consisting primarily of ethylene, ethane, propylene and propane to commonly accepted specifications (i.e., to ethylene and propylene product specifications and to ethane and propane recycle specifications).

The correlations are based on the data that are summarized below on Table A where the "A" designation refers to ethylene, "B" refers to ethane, "C" refers to the propylene species and "D" refers to propane. Table A is believed to be valuable in itself, for predicting optimal tower operating pressures for feeds with different compositions from that which are disclosed herein.

The following constraints are applicable:

1. The correlation assumes cooling water is used only according to common practice.

2. Reboiler heat is supplied using steam according to common practice.

3. Refrigeration is available according to common practice.

4. Each tower receives only a single feed and produces two product effluents.

In order to use the correlation, it is necessary to calculate three important temperatures that mathematically embody the effect of pressure on operating costs and capital investment requirements. These temperatures are all evaluated using standard bubble point and dew point temperature estimation procedures, but at 485 psia pressures for each mixture that is considered. The optimal tower operating pressure, P* in psia, is thus determined by the equation: ##EQU1## where: T_(FB) =tower feed mixture bubble point temperature (°R) evaluated at 485 psia

T.sub.φB =tower overhead product mixture bubble point temperature (°R) evaluated at 485 psia

T_(BD) =tower bottom product mixture dew point temperature (°R) evaluated at 485 psia.

The correlation fits the observations in Table A with a standard deviation of ±15.3 psia i.e., between about 290 psia and about 680 psia. The observed and predicted optimal presure deviations are presented in Table B. The nonlinear parameter confidence intervals for the parameters indicate that all parameters are statistically significant.

                  TABLE A                                                          ______________________________________                                         Data base for empirical pressure correlation                                                                OPTIMAL                                           Tower       Temperatures (°F.)                                                                       PRESSURE                                          Number Split    T.sub.FB                                                                               T.sub..0.B                                                                            T.sub.BD                                                                             (PSIA)                                    ______________________________________                                         11     AB/CD    48.67   25.47  168.74                                                                               450.0                                     12     A/B      25.47   18.55  65.85 669.3                                     13     C/D      167.89  167.06 182.94                                                                               .sup. 291.3.sup.a                         14     A/BCD    48.67   18.55  137.43                                                                               544.3                                     15     ABC/D    48.67   47.32  182.94                                                                               410.2                                     16     A/BC     47.33   18.55  135.42                                                                               538.9                                     17     AB/C     47.33   25.46  167.86                                                                               496.7                                     18     B/CD     121.05  62.28  168.75                                                                               431.6                                     19     BC/D     121.05  118.96 182.93                                                                               350.2                                     110    B/C      118.96  62.28  167.87                                                                               435.9                                     ______________________________________                                          .sup.a Optimal condition using 10 lb steam, near optimal using hot quench      liquid.                                                                  

                  TABLE B                                                          ______________________________________                                         Observed and predicted optimal pressures and residuals.                        Tower        Optimal Pressures (PSIA)                                          Number  Split    Observed   Calculated                                                                             Residual                                   ______________________________________                                         11      AB/CD    450.0      475.4   25.4                                       12      A/B      669.3      670.5   1.2                                        13      C/D.sup.a                                                                               291.3      301.0   9.7                                        14      A/BCD    544.3      538.7   -5.6                                       15      ABC/D    410.2      413.2   3.0                                        16      A/BC     538.9      541.1   2.2                                        17      AB/C     496.7      475.8   -20.9                                      18      B/CD     431.6      434.0   2.4                                        19      BC/D     350.2      336.8   -13.4                                      110     B/C      435.9      434.3   -1.6                                       ______________________________________                                          STANDARD DEVIATION = ± 15.3 psia                                            .sup.a Optimal condition using 10 lb steam, near optimal using hot quench      liquid.                                                                  

Referring now to the drawings, as illustrated in FIG. 1, the feed stream 1, containing primarily ethane, ethylene, propane and propylene, is passed through pump 2 and heat exchanger 4 into a first distillation tower 11, which is typically a sieve or bubble-cap tray fractionating column. The vaporous overhead 5 is condensed in condenser 7 with the condensate accumlated in pressure vessel 8, a part being returned as reflux through pump 9 and line 10 and the balance being removed through line 14. The first tower 11 in this embodiment is operated at from about 400 psia to about 600 psia, preferably, from about 460 psia to about 480 psia, so as to produce an overhead in line 14 containing only ethane and ethylene.

This C₂ fraction is then passed through pump 15 and heat exchanger 17 into a second distillation tower 12, which is also conveniently of the sieve tray type. The gaseous overhead 18 is condensed in condenser 20 with the condensate accumulated in pressure vessel 21, a part being returned as reflux through pump 22 and line 23 and ethylene is removed through line 24. A reboiled circuit including pump 25 and heat exchanger 27 is used at the bottom and ethane is removed through line 28. The second tower 12 is operated at from about 600 psia to about 700 psia, preferably, from about 660 psia to about 680 psia.

The first tower 11 is also provided with a reboiler circuit including pump 29 and heat exchanger 31. The bottoms removed through line 32 containing propane and propylene. This bottoms stream is passed through pump 33 and heat exchanger 35 into a third distillation tower 13, which is also conveniently of the sieve tray type. The gaseous overhead 36 is condensed in condenser 38 with the condensate accumulated in pressure vessel 39, a part being returned as reflux through pump 40 and line 41 and propylene removed through line 42. A reboiler circuit including pump 43 and heat exchanger 45 is used at the bottom and propane is removed through line 46. The third tower 113 is operated at between about 100 psia and about 170 psia, preferably, from between about 120 and about 140 psia.

In accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention, as illustrated in FIG. 2, the distillation sequence of the process is altered. As shown in FIG. 2, the feed stream 101, containing primarily ethane, ethylene, propane and propylene, is passed through pump 102 and heat exchanger 104 into a first tower 114, which is typically a sieve tray fractionating column. The gaseous overhead 105 is condensed in condenser 107 with the condensate accumulated in pressure vessel 103, a part being returned as reflux through pump 109 and line 110 and ethylene being removed through line 111. The first distillation tower 14 is operated at a pressure of from about 500 psia to about 650 psia, preferably, from about 550 to about 570 psia.

The first tower 114 is also provided with a reboiler circuit including pump 112 and heat exchanger 116. The bottoms removed through line 117 containing ethane, propane and propylene. This bottom stream is passed through pump 119 and heat exchanger 121 into a second distillation tower 118, which is also conveniently of the sieve tray type. The gaseous overhead 122 is condensed in condenser 124 with the condensate accumulated in pressure vessel 125, a part being returned as reflux through pump 126 and line 127 and ethane removed through line 128. The second tower 18 is operated at a pressure of from about 390 psia to about 520 psia, preferably from about 410 psia to about 430 psia.

The second tower 18 is also provided with a reboiler circuit including pump 129 and heat exchanger 131. The bottoms removed through line 132 containing propane and propylene. This bottom stream is passed through pump 133 and heat exchanger 135 into a third tower 113, which is also conveniently of the sieve tray type. The gaseous overhead 136 is condensed in condenser 138 with the condensate accumulated in pressure vessel 139, a part being returned as reflux through pump 140 and line 141 and propylene removed through line 142. The third tower 113 is operated at a pressure of from about 100 psia to about 170 psia, preferably at from about 120 psia to about 140 psia.

The third distillation tower 113 is also provided with a reboiler circuit including pump 143 and heat exchanger 145 and propane is removed through line 146.

As noted in the above discussion, the operational pressures of the distillation columns 11 and 12, according to the present invention, are substantially different from those normally contemplated by the art. As a benchmark for purposes of comparison, a current commercial process utilizing the configuration of FIG. 1 utilizes pressures of about 350 psia in tower 11, about 300 psia in tower 12 and about 250 psia in tower 13. Such operating pressures are generally arrived at by consideration of the relative volatility of the components to be separated, i.e., the degree of separation attainable at a given pressure, along with certain cost factors such as tower size and available utilities.

In particular, for towers 11 and 12, it is well known that the relative volatilities of the species separated decrease with increasing tower pressures. This simple observation by itself suggests that the minimum vapor requirements increase with increasing pressures. Consequently, these tower condenser and reboiler duties have also been assumed to invariably increase with pressure according to the common belief of those skilled in the art. Therefore, common practice has been to operate towers 11 and 12 of the sequence in FIG. 1 at pressures which are substantially below the economically favored conditions.

In addition, it has been common practice to operate towers 11 and 12 at substantially less than economic pressures due to concerns for hydraulic instabilities. However, because of significant improvements in on-line process control in recent years, these stability concerns are not detrimental to the overall value of the invention. On the other hand, stability considerations enhance the value of the sequence in FIG. 2, relative to the configuration that is shown as FIG. 1, i.e., towers 14 and 18.

Also, it has been common practice to operate towers 12 and 13 at pressures that are substantially different from the optimal conditions in order to permit heat transfer from the tower 13 condenser to the tower 12 reboiler. This practice mistakenly assumes that heat exchanger matching between these two towers is valuable. However, I have found that the most important economic considerations are the condenser costs for tower 12 and the reboiler costs for tower 13 which are adversely affected by this current practice of optimization. On the other hand, my invention reduces the costs of these latter two quantities substantially.

I have discovered that significantly different operating pressures result in substantial process economies, primarily with respect to the cooling requirements of reflux condensers and feed heat exchangers, with only moderate increases in the capital expenditures necessary to achieve desirable separation. Also, my invention permits a novel use of cooling water to supply reboiler heat to propylene/propane towers. Alternatively, my invention permits the optimum use of reboiler steam or hot quench oil. Moreover, in a preferred embodiment, favorable synergisms between the distillation sequence and the tower operating pressures have been discovered that substantially reduce the system utility requirements. Illustrative of the favorable results obtainable at higher pressures, is the effect of operating pressure on the ethane/propylene splitter (tower 11, FIG. 1) as shown in Table 1.

                  TABLE I                                                          ______________________________________                                                                         Feed &  Latent                                                         Minimum Reflux  Heat of                                      Over-             Vapor   Condenser                                                                              Vaporiz-                               Pres- head     Relative rate    Duties  ation                                  sure  Temp.    Volatil- (lb-    (10.sup.6 BTU/                                                                         (BTU lb-                               (psia)                                                                               (F.°)                                                                            ity      moles/hr)                                                                              hr.)    mole)                                  ______________________________________                                         200   -29.4    3.751    5348    38.73   4366.7                                 250   -15.8    3.405    5563    38.39   4096.7                                 300   -4.2     3.133    5730    37.16   3844.4                                 350   5.9      2.907    5954    34.24   3590.8                                 400   15.0     2.714    6192    31.25   3346.1                                 450   23.1     2.543    6452    26.99   3082.7                                 ______________________________________                                    

a--Temperature of the overhead vapor.

b--Ethane/propylene relative volatility evaluated at the overhead vapor temperature.

c--The pinch point for the tower is located below the feed tray.

d--Latent heat is for the overhead product of tower 11, as set forth in Table 2.

As may be readily ascertained, the relative volatility, of course, decreases with increasing pressure. This change also increases the minimum vapor requirements for higher pressures, but the overall condenser duties decrease. This latter result occurs because of reduced latent heats of vaporization at the higher pressures. These results are set forth for the tower 11

                                      TABLE 2                                      __________________________________________________________________________     OVERALL MATERIAL FLOWRATES FOR DISTILLATION SEQUENCE OF FIG. 1                            Tower 11   Tower 12  Tower 13                                                             Ethylene                                                                            Ethane                                                                              Propylene                                                                            Propane                                  Feed       Overheads                                                                            Bottoms                                                                             Product                                                                             Product                                                                             Product                                                                              Product                                  __________________________________________________________________________     Ethylene                                                                             3180.                                                                               3179.84                                                                              0.16 3179.                                                                               0.84 0.159 0.001                                    Ethane                                                                               670. 669.52                                                                               0.48 1.24 668.25                                                                              0.472 0.004                                    Propylene                                                                            1053.                                                                               12.   1041.                                                                               0.12 11.88                                                                               1039.9                                                                               1.1                                      Propane                                                                              85.  8.    77.  0.08 7.92 9.5   67.5                                     __________________________________________________________________________      overheads (FIG. 1) as shown in Table 2, however, similar trends are      observed for all columns.

The surprising thing is the fact that although the minimum vapor requirements increase with pressure, the latent heat of vaporization decreases with pressure with a net effect that the heat of condensation decreases with increasing pressure for those towers 11, 12, 13, 113 and 118. With a propylene/propane splitter this is not so. In other words, the minimum vapor requirements increase faster than the latent heat of vaporization decreases. Therefore with that tower the relative volatility decreases to force operation at the lower pressure with the hot oil quencher around 290 psia and with the cooling water around 130 psia. For every different mixture there are different conditions.

The nominal product specification used in Table 2 are:

Ethylene product: <0.05% ethane

Ethane product: <0.15% ethylene

Propylene product: ≦1% propane

Propane product: ≦2% propylene.

Moreover, in addition to the reduced latent heat of vaporization, the overhead temperature increases, thus, allowing the use of less costly coolant streams, (i.e., higher temperature coolant streams).

In FIG. 4 a tower 213 which is similar to the third tower 13. Propylene/propane gas is fed through heat exchanger 235 into the tower 213 and the gaseous overhead 236 is condensed in condenser 238 and the condensate discharge through line 242. A part of the propylene is returned via pump 240 and line 241 to the tower 213. As illustrated in table 13, hereinafter, the tower of FIG. 4 is operated at a pressure of between about 100 psia to about 170 psia and preferably at 130 psia. Under such conditions, hot cooling water from a conventional cooling system can be used for providing heat for a reboiler circuit which includes pump 243 and heat exchanger 245. Propane is discharged through line 246. The hot cooling water is supplied from a heat exchanger 250 via line 244 and returned thereto as cold cooling water via line 249. This heat exchanger also has an outside process stream via line 251. The efficiency of the system of FIG. 4 is demonstrated in table 13 hereof.

In FIG. 3, the third tower 313 is illustrated as receiving a propylene/propane feed from a second tower (not shown). This propane and propylene is fed through a heat exchanger 335 into tower 313, which also has sieve trays. The gaseous overhead 336 is condensed in condenser 338 with a portion of the condensate being returned via pump 340 to the tower 313. The propylene product is discharged via line 342.

This third tower 313 is operated at a pressure of from about 250 psia to about 300 psia and preferably at approximately 290 psia. This third tower 313 is also provided with a reboiler circuit including pump 343 and heat exchanger 345, the propane being removed through line 346.

In the present embodiment, the two heat exchangers 335 and 345 are provided with heat via lines 334 and 344, respectively, the heat medium being liquid from a hot quench line 351. Lines 353 and 349, respectively return the heating liquid or medium from the heat exchangers 335 and 345 respectively to the cold quench return line 354.

It will be understood by those skilled in the art that hot ethylene reactor products are fed through a heat exchanger 350 via a line 355 and discharged therefrom via line 356 as cool ethylene reactor products to a separator. The hot quench fluid passes from the heat exchanger 350 along line 351 to a quench cooling system 357 and is returned to the quench system 350 via line 354. The quench cooling system discharges the excess quench heat to the environment via line 358.

Table 16 illustrates the efficiency of the system of Table 16.

Having generally described this invention, a further understanding can be obtained by reference to certain specific examples which are provided herein for purposes of illustration only and are not intended to be limiting unless otherwise specified.

In all the examples which follow, the capital investment requirements are based upon short-cut design methods consisting of a modified Fenske-Underwood-Gilliland technique and the cost correlations developed by Guthrie ("Data and Techniques for Preliminary Capital Cost Estimating," Chem. Eng. (Mar. 24, 1969) p. 114). The costs have been factored to mid--1979 using the M & S equipment cost index (a factor of 2.2.)

Equilibrium K values were estimated using the Chao-Sender calculational method and verified from experimental data published in the literature. Latent heats or vaporization were estimated from the Watson correlation. The design methodology considers changes in molar flowrates at different points in the tower and, therefore, the effects of latent and sensible heat changes.

The annual utility costs were calculated from the assumed operating schedule of 8500 hrs/yr., the estimated utility requirements for the process, and the utility cost schedule that is shown as Table 3 (based on typical on-site costs). Additional equipment specifications that are used in determining tower heights and equipment costs are set forth in Table 4.

                  TABLE 3                                                          ______________________________________                                         Utility         Available T.sup.a                                                                         Cost.sup.b,c                                        ______________________________________                                         Cooling Water   75         0.15                                                Propylene       40         2.86                                                Refrigerant     0          7.51                                                                -40        11.19                                               Ethylene        -75        13.97                                               Refrigerant     -110       18.35                                                               -140       23.04                                               Steam           239        6.63                                                ______________________________________                                          .sup.a All temperatures in °F.                                          .sup.b Costs have been truncated to the nearest cent.                          .sup.c All costs in dollars per million BTU's transferred.               

                  TABLE 4                                                          ______________________________________                                         Tower          =        Carbon-Steel vertical                                                          pressure vessel with                                                           sieve trays spaced at                                                          1.5 ft.                                                Reflux Condenser                                                                              =        Carbon-steel                                           Reboiler                shell-and-tube                                         Feed Heat Exchanger     exchangers                                             Feed Pump      =        Carbon-steel                                           Reboiler Pump           centrifugal                                            Reflux Pump             pumps and drivers                                      Reflux         =        Carbon-steel                                                                   horizontal pressure                                                            vessel with the                                                                length equal to 2                                                              times the diameter.                                                            Nominal space time                                                             is 7.5 minutes.                                        ______________________________________                                    

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 1

In accordance with FIG. 1, a separation process was run in accordance with conventional procedures to obtain the separation set forth in Table 2, above. A summary of the process operating conditions is set forth in Table 5. Equipment specification for the various towers are set forth in Tables 6, 7 and 8. The results are set forth in Tables 17, 18A and 19.

                                      TABLE 5                                      __________________________________________________________________________                                       Utilities (10.sup.6 BTU/hr)                                 P   T.sup.b                                                                             Rates (1.sup.b -moles/hr)                                                                Reflux                                                                               Feed                                   Tower                                                                              Split.sup.a                                                                           Tray                                                                               (psia)                                                                             (°F.)                                                                        Vapor                                                                               Liquid                                                                              Condenser                                                                            Heat Exch.                                                                           Reboiler                         __________________________________________________________________________     11  AB/CD  Top 350.0                                                                              2.5  7707 3838 -27.7                                        69  Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               352.0                                                                              32.2 6190 2320       0.5                                               Bottom                                                                             354.0                                                                              140.6                                                                               4510 5628             20.4                             12  A/B    Top 300.0                                                                              -14.1                                                                               11902                                                                               8722 -44.6                                        140 Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               302.                                                                               -7.5 11516                                                                               8336       3.2                                               Bottom                                                                             304.                                                                               27.8 9876 10565            40.2                             13  C/D    Top 250.0                                                                              111.3                                                                               8852 7802 -46.7                                        291 Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               252.                                                                               112.3                                                                               8858 7808       0.1                                               Bottom                                                                             254.                                                                               126.6                                                                               8445 8514             44.2                             __________________________________________________________________________      .sup.a A = Ethylene                                                            B = Ethane                                                                     C = Propylene                                                                  D = Propane                                                                    .sup.b Temperature of the bubble point liquid overflow.                  

                  TABLE 6                                                          ______________________________________                                         tower 11                                                                                                          Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                        Item     Description     ($1000)   ($1000)                                     ______________________________________                                         Tower    69 Actual Trays 743                                                            8.6 Ft. Diam., 114 Ft.                                                         High                                                                  Reflux   27.7 MBTU/hr, 6270 Ft.sup.2                                                                    303       2,632                                       Condenser                                                                               (-40° Propylene)                                               Reflux   6837 gallons    57                                                    Drum                                                                           Reboiler 20.5 MBTU/hr, 2072 Ft.sup.2                                                                    148       974                                                  239° Steam                                                     Feed Heat                                                                               0.5 MBTU/hr, 2072 Ft.sup.2                                                                     20        27                                          Exchanger                                                                               239 steam                                                             Reflux Pump                                                                             14.8 BHP, 454 GPM                                                                              11        3                                           Reboiler 5.1 BHP, 740 GPM                                                                               5         1                                           Pump                                                                                    TOTALS          1,287     3,637                                       ______________________________________                                    

                  TABLE 7                                                          ______________________________________                                         tower 12                                                                                                          Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                        Item     Description     ($1000)   ($1000)                                     ______________________________________                                         Tower    140 Actual Trays                                                                               1,460                                                          11. Ft. Diam., 220 Ft.                                                         High                                                                  Reflux   44.6 MBTU/hr, 17,231                                                                           560       4,242                                       Condenser                                                                               Ft.sup.2 (-40° Propylene)                                      Reflux   10,214 gallons  71                                                    Drum                                                                           Reboiler 40.2 MBTU/hr, 6682 Ft.sup.2                                                                    304                                                            (Matched with                                                                  Tower 13)                                                             Feed Heat                                                                               3.2 MBTU/hr, 353 Ft.sup.2                                                                      45        182                                         Exchanger                                                                               (-40° propylene)                                               Reflux Pump                                                                             48 BHP, 998     24        10                                          Reboiler 5 BHP, 1307 GPM 6         1                                           Pump                                                                                    TOTALS          2,166     4,435                                       ______________________________________                                    

                  TABLE 8                                                          ______________________________________                                         tower 13 and 113                                                                                                  Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                        Item     Description     ($1000)   ($1000)                                     ______________________________________                                         Tower    291 Actual Trays                                                                               2,188                                                          11.5 Ft. Diam., 446 Ft.                                                        high                                                                  Reflux   46.7 MBTU/Hr, 1080 Ft.sup.2                                                                    102       8                                           Condenser                                                                               (matched with tower 12,                                                        excess with cooling                                                            water)                                                                Reflux   10,681 gallons  70                                                    Drum                                                                           Reboiler 44.2 MBTU/hr, 3917 Ft.sup.2                                                                    205       2,102                                                (239° F. steam)                                                Feed Heat                                                                               0.1 MBTU/hr, 14 Ft.sup.2                                                                       5         7                                           Exchanger                                                                               (239° F. steam)                                                Reflux Pump                                                                             114 BHP, 1255 GPM                                                                              41        23                                          Reboiler 5 BHP, 1455 GPM 6         1                                           Pump                                                                                    TOTALS          2,617     2,141                                       ______________________________________                                    

EXAMPLE 1

In accordance with FIGS. 1 and 4, a separation process was run in accordance with this invention to obtain the separation set forth in Table 2, above. A summary of the process operating conditions is set forth in Table 9. Equipment specifications for the various towers are set forth in Tables 10, 11 and 12, The results are set forth in Tables 17, 18A and 19.

                                      TABLE 9                                      __________________________________________________________________________                                      Utilities (10.sup.6 BTU/hr)                                  P   T.sup.b                                                                            Rates (1.sup.b -moles/hr)                                                                Reflux                                                                               Feed                                    Tower                                                                              Split.sup.a                                                                           Tray                                                                               (psia)                                                                             (°F.)                                                                       Vapor                                                                               Liquid                                                                              Condenser                                                                            Heat Exch.                                                                           Reboiler                          __________________________________________________________________________     11  AB/CD  Top 450.0                                                                              20.0                                                                               7835 3966 -24.1                                         63  Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               452.0                                                                              51.62                                                                              6908 3039       3.9                                                Bottom                                                                             454.0                                                                              162.0                                                                              4575 5693             17.4                              12  A/B    Top 669.0                                                                              42.2                                                                               10039                                                                               6858 -16.8                                         227 Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               671.                                                                               49.9                                                                               20309                                                                               17128      9.5                                                Bottom                                                                             673.                                                                               88.6                                                                               11786                                                                               12475            13.2                              13  C/D    Top 123.0                                                                              59.6                                                                               7302 6252 -46.1                                         229 Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               125.                                                                               61.6                                                                               7303 6253       -0.005                                             Bottom                                                                             127.                                                                               74.6                                                                               6382 6450             40.4                              __________________________________________________________________________      .sup.a A = Ethylene                                                            B = Ethane                                                                     C = Propylene                                                                  D = Propane                                                                    .sup.b Temperature of the bubble point liquid overflow.                  

                  TABLE 10                                                         ______________________________________                                         tower 11                                                                                                          Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                        Item     Description     ($1000)   ($1000)                                     ______________________________________                                         Tower    63 Actual Trays 699                                                            8.2 Ft. Diam., 104 Ft.                                                         high                                                                  Reflux   24.1 MBTU/Hr,   478       1,540                                       Condenser                                                                               11,200 Ft.sup.2                                                                (0° propylene)                                                 Reflux   7035 gallons    63                                                    Drum                                                                           Reboiler 17.4 MBTU/hr, 2251 Ft.sup.2                                                                    169       827                                                  (239° F. steam)                                                Feed Heat                                                                               3.9 MBTU/hr, 927 Ft.sup.2                                                                      95        5                                           Exchanger                                                                               (cooling water to                                                              heat feed)                                                            Reflux Pump                                                                             14 BHP, 475 GPM 10        3                                           Reboiler 5 BHP, 759 GPM  5         1                                           Pump                                                                                    TOTALS          1,519     2,376                                       ______________________________________                                    

                  TABLE 11                                                         ______________________________________                                         tower 12                                                                                                          Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                        Item     Description     ($1000)   ($1000)                                     ______________________________________                                         Tower    227 Actual Trays                                                                               2,555                                                          11.7 Ft. Diam., 350 Ft.                                                        high                                                                  Reflux   16.8 MBTU/Hr,   286       1,074                                       Condenser                                                                               3990 Ft.sup.2                                                                  (0° propylene)                                                 Reflux   8957 gallons    85                                                    Drum                                                                           Reboiler 13.2 MBTU/hr,   710       76                                                   16092 Ft.sup.2                                                                 (cooling water to heat)                                               Feed Heat                                                                               9.5 MBTU/hr, 1836 Ft.sup.2                                                                     173       12                                          Exchanger                                                                               (cooling water to heat)                                               Reflux Pump                                                                             58 BHP, 816 GPM 27        12                                          Reboiler 6 BHP, 1621 GPM 6         1                                           Pump                                                                           Feed Pump                                                                               93 BHP, 473 GPM 36        19                                                   TOTALS          3,878     1,194                                       ______________________________________                                    

                  TABLE 12                                                         ______________________________________                                         tower 213                                                                                                         Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                        Item     Description     ($1000)   ($1000)                                     ______________________________________                                         Tower    229 Actual Trays                                                                               1,905                                                          12.4 Ft. Diam., 353 Ft.                                                        high                                                                  Reflux   46.1 MBTU/Hr,   594       1,120                                       Condenser                                                                               23,408 Ft.sup.2                                                                (40° propylene)                                                Reflux   8,561 gallons   55                                                    Drum                                                                           Reboiler 40.4 MBTU/hr,   673       56                                                   28,323 Ft.sup.2                                                                (cooling water for heat)                                              Feed Heat                                                                               0.005 MBTU/hr, 1 Ft.sup.2                                                                      0.8       0.1                                         Exchanger                                                                               (40° F. Propylene)                                             Reflux Pump                                                                             76 BHP, 977 GPM 32        15                                          Reboiler 5 BHP, 1069 GPM 6         1                                           Pump                                                                                    TOTALS          3,266     1,192                                       ______________________________________                                    

EXAMPLE 2

In accordance with FIG. 2, a separation process was run, in accordance with this invention, to obtain product streams as defined in Table 2, above. A summary of the process operating conditions is set forth in Table 13. Equipment specifications for the various towers are set forth in Tables 14, 15 and 16. The results are set forth in Tables 17, 18A and 19.

                                      TABLE 13                                     __________________________________________________________________________                                      Utilities (10.sup.6 BTU/hr)                                  P   T.sup.b                                                                            Rates (1.sup.b -moles/hr)                                                                Reflux                                                                               Feed                                    Tower                                                                              Split.sup.a                                                                           Tray                                                                               (psia)                                                                             (°F.)                                                                       Vapor                                                                               Liquid                                                                              Condenser                                                                            Heat Exch.                                                                           Reboiler                          __________________________________________________________________________     14  AB/CD  Top 517.0                                                                              23. 13489                                                                               10309                                                                               -36.3                                         209 Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               519.0                                                                              50. 15906                                                                               12725      -0.1                                               Bottom                                                                             521.0                                                                              127.                                                                               10837                                                                               12644            35.9                              18  A/B    Top 432.0                                                                              53. 3203 2514 -10.7                                         74  Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               434.                                                                               114.                                                                               2679 1990       -0.2                                               Bottom                                                                             436.                                                                               158.                                                                               2329 3447             9.2                               13  C/D    Top 123.0                                                                              60. 7302 6252 -46.1                                         229 Actual Trays                                                                          Feed                                                                               125.                                                                               62. 7303 6253       -0.005                                             Bottom                                                                             127.                                                                               75. 6382 6450             40.4                              __________________________________________________________________________

                  TABLE 14                                                         ______________________________________                                         tower 114                                                                                                         Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                        Item     Description     ($1000)   ($1000)                                     ______________________________________                                         Tower    204 Actual Trays                                                                               2,373                                                          12.5 Ft. Diam., 315 Ft.                                                        high                                                                  Reflux   36.3 MBTU/Hr,   627       2,316                                       Condenser                                                                               15,704 Ft.sup.2                                                                (0° propylene)                                                 Reflux   11,880 gallons  92                                                    Drum                                                                           Reboiler 35.9 MBTU/hr, 3453 Ft.sup.2                                                                    235       1,707                                                (239° F. steam)                                                Feed Heat                                                                               0.1 MBTU/hr, 28 Ft.sup.2                                                                       10        9                                           Exchanger                                                                               (0° F. Propylene)                                              Reflux Pump                                                                             75 BHP, 1211 GPM                                                                               32        15                                          Reboiler 6 BHP, 1675 GPM 7         1                                           Pump                                                                           Feed Pump                                                                               44 BHP, 641 GPM 22        9                                                    TOTALS          3,398     4,057                                       ______________________________________                                    

                  TABLE 15                                                         ______________________________________                                         tower 118                                                                                                           Annual                                                               Capital   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                      Item     Description       ($1000)   ($1000)                                   ______________________________________                                         Tower    74 Actual Trays   501                                                          5.5 Ft. Diam., 120 Ft.                                                         high                                                                  Reflux   10.7 MBTU/Hr, 7203 Ft.sup.2                                                                      354       261                                       Condenser                                                                               (40° propylene)                                                Reflux   3,232 gallons     43                                                  Drum                                                                           Reboiler 9.2 MBTU/hr, 1135 Ft.sup.2                                                                       107       437                                                (239° F. steam)                                                Feed Heat                                                                               0.2 MBTU/hr, 20 Ft.sup.2                                                                         8         4                                         Exchanger                                                                               (40° F. Propylene)                                             Reflux Pump                                                                             12 BHP, 338 GMP   9         2                                         Reboiler 6 BHP, 386 GPM    5         1                                         Pump                                                                                    TOTALS            1,027     705                                       ______________________________________                                    

                  TABLE 16                                                         ______________________________________                                         tower 313                                                                                                           Annual                                                               Captial   Utility                                                              Investment                                                                               Cost                                      Item     Description       ($1000)   ($1000)                                   ______________________________________                                         Tower    299 Actual Trays  2,272                                                        11.5 Ft. Diam., 458 Ft.                                                        high                                                                  Reflux   47.2 MBTU/Hr, 34,686 Ft.sup.2                                                                    876       73                                        Condenser                                                                               (cooling water)                                                       Reflux   11,511 gallons    76                                                  Drum                                                                           Reboiler 44.9 MBTU/hr, 4475 Ft.sup.2                                                                      232       57                                                 (190° F. hot water)                                            Feed Heat                                                                               0.2 MBTU/hr, 18 Ft.sup.2                                                                         6         0.3                                       Exchanger                                                                               (190° F. hot water)                                            Reflux Pump                                                                             125 BHP, 1365 GPM 44        25                                        Reboiler 6 BHP, 1589 GPM   7         1                                         Pump                                                                                    TOTALS            3,513     156                                       ______________________________________                                          VC = 1135                                                                      Tower 13 (using 190° F. Hot Water)                                      Tower Pressure = 290 psia                                                

Table 17 summarizes the utility requirements, based on the operating parameters of Tables 5, 9 and 13, for each of the columns in the Examples. Available utilities were propylene refrigerant (-40°, 0° and 40° F.), cooling water (75° F.) and hot water (190° F.). Utility selection was based on a design criteria of a minimum 7.5° F. temperature differential across the heat transfer surface. As may be readily ascertained, operation at optimal pressures (Example 1) or at optimal pressures with a modified distillation sequence (Example 2) allows the use of less expensive utilities, (i.e., less refrigeration is needed and cooling water may be used economically as a heating medium).

                  TABLE 17                                                         ______________________________________                                                        Utility Temperature.sup.a,b (°F.)                        Tower       Split    Reflux   Feed   Reboiler                                  ______________________________________                                         Comp. Ex.                                                                              11      AB/CD    -40    239    239                                     1       12      A/B      -40    -40    Matched                                         13      C/D      Matched                                                                               239    190                                     Ex. 1   11      AB/CD    0      100    239                                             12      A/B      0      100    100                                             13      C/D      40     40     100                                     Ex. 2   14      A/BCD    0      0      239                                             18      B/CD     40     40     239                                             13      C/D      40     40     100                                     ______________________________________                                          .sup.a Propylene refrigerant was available at -40, 0 and 40° F.         Cooling water was available at 100° F.                                  .sup.b Steam was available at 239° F.                             

Table 18A summarizes the energy demand for each of the columns in the Examples. Energy demand is calculated using Table 18B which shows the number of BTUs which must be expended for each BTU of heat transferred in the process, for the various utilities available. As may be readily ascertained, operation at the optimal pressures (Example 1) or at the optimal pressures with a modified distillation sequence (Example 2) reduces energy demand to about 43% or 59%, respectively, of that of the conventional process (Comparative Example 1).

                  TABLE 18A                                                        ______________________________________                                                               Energy Demand                                                                  (10.sup.6 BTU ( )/hr)                                    Tower        Split    Reflux    Feed  Reboiler                                 ______________________________________                                         Comp. 11         AB/CD    54.6    0.8   30.8                                   Ex. 1 12         A/B      87.9    6.3   0.0                                          13         C/D      0.3     0.2   66.3                                   ENERGY USE = 247.2                                                             Ex. 1 11         AB/CD    31.8    0.2   26.1                                         12         A/B      22.2    0.4   0.6                                          13         C/D      23.2    0.0   1.8                                    ENERGY USE = 106.3                                                             Ex. 2 14         A/BCD    48.0    0.1   53.9                                         18         B/CD     5.4     0.1   13.8                                         13         C/D      23.2    0.0   1.8                                    ENERGY USE = 146.3                                                             ______________________________________                                    

                  TABLE 18B                                                        ______________________________________                                          UTILITY     (°F.)AVAILABLE T                                                                     ##STR1##                                             ______________________________________                                         Cooling Water                                                                                75         0.046                                                 Propylene     40         0.504                                                 Refrigerant   0          1.321                                                              -40         1.970                                                 Ethylene     -75         2.458                                                 Refrigerant -110         3.230                                                             -140         4.054                                                 Steam        239         1.5                                                   ______________________________________                                          .sup.a BTU's expended on a thermal basis in order to transfer one BTU of       heat in the process.                                                     

Table 19 summarizes the capital investment and annual utilities costs for each of the Examples. As may be readily ascertained, operation at the optimal pressures for Example 1 results in an estimated 43% increase in capital requirements, but reduces the utility costs by 53%. Example 2 is estimated to require 27% more capital investment than current practice, but reduces the utility costs by 42% per annum.

                  TABLE 9                                                          ______________________________________                                                                              Annual                                                             Capital     Utility                                                            Investment  Cost                                      Tower           Split    ($1000)     ($1000)                                   ______________________________________                                         Comp. Ex.                                                                              11          AB/CD    1287      3637                                    1       12          A/B      2166      4435                                            13          C/D      2617      2141                                            TOTALS               6070      10213                                   Ex. 1   11          AB/CD    1519      2376                                            12          A/B      3878      1194                                            13          C/D      3266      1192                                            TOTALS               8663      4762                                    Ex. 2   14          A/BCD    3398      4057                                            18          B/CD     1027       705                                            13          C/D      3266      1192                                            TOTALS               7691      5954                                    ______________________________________                                     

I claim:
 1. Method of optimizing the expense of the recovery of C₂ /C₃ hydrocarbons from a fluid mixture consisting essentially of ethane, ethylene propane and propylene through fractional distillation comprising:(a) operating a system of distillation towers in a distillation system in which each tower receives a single feed and produces two effluents and wherein certain of the towers has a reboiler wherein the pressure of each tower is within ±15 psia of the pressure, calculated from the formulae: ##EQU2## and wherein: P*=the pressure of each tower in psiaT_(FB) =tower feed mixture bubble point temperature (°R) evaluated at 485 psia T.sub.φB =tower overhead product mixture bubble point temperature (°R) evaluated at 485 psia T_(BD) =tower bottom product mixture dew point temperature (°R) evaluated at 485 psia (b) circulating cooling water which has been heated during a heat exchange cooling operation by heat from one of said towers to a temperature of from 80° F. to 130° F., to said reboiler and back to said heat exchanger; (c) feeding at least a portion of said fluid mixture to the internals of the other of said towers; (d) discharging said recovering the effluent distillate product from the top of said internals; and (e) discharging the effluent bottom product from the bottom of said internals.
 2. The method defined in claim 1 wherein said cooling water passing through said reboiler has a temperature drop of in excess of 15° F. in said reboiler and wherein the pressure of said fluid in said internals is between 100 psia and 170 psia.
 3. The method of claim 1 wherein said distillate product is essentially polypropylene and said bottom product is essentially propane. 